so new question, is there a way to replace just one of the pins, instead of buying a whole new resetter? I can solder, if I can find a replacement pin, I can probably fix this.
Is the third pin thru the plastic shell, or is it stuck inside the hole? If it’s not sticking out, then it may be simply stuck in the case. You can try taking the resetter apart (two small screws are located under the label), then gently remove the green computer board with pins attached, to see if the three pins stick out equal length or not.